YSL Peace Green vs. Ever After 2 Peace in A Pod

This Spring Yves Saint Laurent released two limited edition polishes, one of them being Peace Green. Everyone wanted that beautiful light mint green with strong pink shimmer and as expected, they flew off the shelves at a hefty price of $27-$28 USD! Something this unique is quite rare in the high end polish world. Typically brands like Chanel, Dior, YSL etc. stick to cremes or subtle shimmers that can be seen in the bottle but not on the nail (I'm looking at you Dior!).

In response, many people tried to find a dupe for Peace Green. Some came close but Peace Green couldn't be copied! Then, the maker of Ever After decided to make an exact dupe of Peace Green based on a sample swatch stick she received. The comparison photo looked promising so I decided to purchase 2 Peace in A Pod for $10.50 USD and put it to the test!

This is a picture heavy post - so let's get started with the pictures first and see if you can guess which one is the YSL and which is the Ever After! All photos were taken in direct sunlight so you can see all that shimmer!

Here they are at another angle:

 

A close up of the two side by side:

 Here are macro shots of each of the polishes - did you figure out which one is which yet?

Lastly, here are some bottle shots:

Did you guess correctly? As you can see, Ever After's 2 Peace in A Pod is not an exact dupe for YSL's Peace Green. There is quite a difference between the base green colour. I would say they are a few shades away from each other with the Ever After being darker than the YSL.

From the macro and bottle shots, you can see Peace Green has a much stronger pink shimmer whereas 2 Peace in A Pod's shimmer does not seem to be as fine and is leaning a bit more yellow/ gold.

Formula wise Peace Green was really good - The consistency was on the thinner side and although it was a thin 3 coater, each coat dried quickly and leveled out nicely. It had a glossy finish and didn't require top coat but Seche Vite was applied anyways for consistency in the comparison. My bottle of 2 Peace in A Pod on the other hand was terribly thick. Despite being thick, I still need 3-4 coats and it did not level out very well. I could not paint one length of my nail without getting streaks. I added about 10 drops of nail polish thinner and re-did the 2 nails with the Ever After on them. While it was manageable, the formula was still streaky and required lots of top coat to hide the streakiness.

Do you think 2 Peace in A Pod by Ever After is a good enough dupe for YSL's Peace Green? Let me know what you think!

Thanks for reading!

*All products mentioned in this post were purchased myself.